(N)one Patent Solution
Interactive 3D Digitization of Pop-Up Picture Books: Between the Demand for Authenticity and Resource Requirements
Historical pop-up books such as Lothar Meggendorfer’s Bewegliche Schattenbilder (Munich, 1886), with mechanical pull and rotating elements hidden between the pages, make their interactive 3D digitization a particularly challenging task. For an exact reconstruction that ensures the authenticity of the physical properties, and especially of the play mechanism of such a book object, the extensive use of non-destructive imaging techniques would, strictly speaking, be required, or alternatively the manual exposure of its ‘inner workings’, invisible to the naked eye – a step that, for conservation reasons, is generally out of the question. Numerous publishers and paper engineers did have their inventions legally protected by patents as early as the nineteenth century: in 1878, for example, Theodor Brand’s revolutionary Sprechendes Bilderbuch or the Theater-Bilderbuch, published by Jakob Ferdinand Schreiber in Esslingen. However, the technical drawings that had to be submitted to patent offices in this context usually provide only a schematic impression of the construction of the work in question, without revealing, for example, the precise positioning of the joints and spirals incorporated into it, or the weight and dimensions of its levers, rotating discs, and tabs. Even when a comprehensively documented restoration report is available – which is anything but the norm – the digital replication of certain mechanical features will inevitably remain hypothetical if radio- or computed tomography is not used.
The problem outlined here, namely how to balance the demand for authenticity with the resources required for the 3D digitization of (not only) book-based interactive materialities, concerns by no means only the interior of such objects, but also their external characteristics, such as the grammage of the paper used, the tightness of the binding, or the resistance encountered when pulling the tabs.
More than that: Which possibilities for interacting with the book in question should actually be preserved in the digital realm – including the unlikely ones and even those that are undesirable? And which forms of damage should be regarded as traces of use with historical value as sources, and which, by contrast, are merely the result of humidity or improper storage? The difficulty of deciding between preservation and correction may be exemplified by the warped bars of the paper lion cage in Oscar Schulz’s Große Menagerie: How can we be sure that they were originally actually flat?
The scientifically appropriate ideal solution to the challenge only roughly outlined here will presumably lie in meticulously documenting all possible variants, decisions made, and interventions carried out – in other words, in combining interactive 3D digitization with the principles of a critical edition. But how prohibitively high would the cost of such an approach be? In his 2016 essay on the three dimensions of the book, Carlos Spoerhase argued that, when digitizing book-based literary culture, one “cannot limit oneself to the theoretical observational stance established since the 1920s and practically settle for transforming vast quantities of analogous printed sheets into digital screen pages.” Given the resources required, however, this proposition can, at least for the time being, probably only be realized on an exemplary basis.
Author: Christian Mathieu


